Hartsel Homes under $900,000

Welcome to Hartsel, Colorado – a hidden gem nestled in the heart of Park County! Known for its breathtaking mountain views and serene landscapes, Hartsel offers a unique blend of rustic charm and modern living. With its strategic location between the bustling towns of Fairplay and Buena Vista, residents enjoy easy access to outdoor adventures, local amenities, and a tight-knit community atmosphere.

Hartsel is a haven for nature enthusiasts, with an abundance of recreational opportunities at your doorstep. Whether you’re an avid hiker, fisherman, or simply someone who enjoys the tranquility of the great outdoors, the nearby Pike National Forest and South Park Reservoir provide endless opportunities for exploration and relaxation. The stunning vistas and fresh mountain air create the perfect backdrop for a peaceful lifestyle.

For those seeking a home in Hartsel, you’ll be delighted to discover a variety of properties available for under $900,000. From charming log cabins to contemporary homes, the real estate market here caters to a range of tastes and budgets. These homes often come with expansive lots, allowing room for gardens, outdoor activities, or simply soaking in the picturesque surroundings.

Hartsel is more than just a place to live; it’s a community where neighbors become friends and the beauty of nature becomes part of your daily life. If you’re looking for a serene escape with affordable housing options, Hartsel, Colorado, might just be the perfect place to call home. Come explore the possibilities and discover your dream retreat in this enchanting mountain town!

Newest Hartsel Homes under $900,000

$449,900

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 9202667 MLS

Welcome to wide-open Colorado living in this beautifully remodeled 3-bedroom, 2-bath home offering 1,392 square feet on 3.25 acres in Hartsel Ranch. Located just a few miles from Hwy 9, this property offers the peaceful South Park setting while remaining convenient to Hartsel and surrounding mountain communities. Inside, thoughtful updates blend with Colorado character. Warm wood ceilings and walls create an inviting mountain feel, while the remodeled kitchen features updated cabinetry, appliances, workspace and an island perfect for gathering. Large windows bring in natural light and showcase the surrounding landscape. Both bathrooms have been refreshed with modern finishes, and three bedrooms offer flexibility for guests or a home office. Additional features include luxury vinyl flooring, a tankless water heater, water filtration/softening system and grid-connected solar panels. An attached garage and unfinished/workshop space provide room for vehicles, tools and gear. Outside, enjoy 3.25 acres, panoramic mountain and valley views, incredible sunsets and room to breathe. Relax on the covered porch and take in the scenery, with additional outdoor structures for storage, gardening or hobbies. The property is also near the site of the proposed Wild Horse Reservoir. Outdoor recreation surrounds Hartsel, including Spinney Mountain Reservoir, Eleven Mile State Park, the South Platte River and Dream Stream, offering fishing, boating, hiking and wildlife viewing. Known as the Heart of Colorado, Hartsel offers fuel, restaurants, a general store, post office, library and local businesses. Fairplay and Buena Vista provide additional shopping and services. Approximate distances are 18 miles to Fairplay, 29 miles to Buena Vista, 41 miles to Breckenridge, 65 miles to Colorado Springs and 104 miles to Denver. Move-in ready, remodeled and situated on acreage with solar and convenient highway access, this is a wonderful opportunity to own a piece of the Colorado high country.

14012 S Chickasaw Rd, Hartsel

$449,900

2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 4939118 MLS

Set on 36 acres in the Colorado high country, this distinctive off-grid Earthship-style home offers privacy, self-sufficiency, year-round water, and the infrastructure for a true mountain homestead. Located in the Thousand Peaks subdivision between Hartsel and Fairplay, the property combines sustainable design, expansive views, agricultural zoning, multiple outbuildings, and approximately 600 feet of year-round Fourmile Creek. Designed for passive solar living, the home features tire-bale construction, south-facing windows, stone floors and walls that absorb and radiate warmth, and a wood-burning stove in the main living area. Aspen tongue-and-groove ceilings, natural stone finishes, and an open floor plan create a warm, rustic interior. The spacious kitchen offers abundant cabinetry and a large island and flows into the dining area and indoor growing space. A 100-square-foot planter allows for year-round gardening. Generously sized bedrooms, a 12x15 loft, root cellar, utility space, and storage add flexibility. The property includes a private well feeding a 600-gallon indoor cistern and an upgraded solar system with solar arrays, a wind turbine, 16 batteries, two new charge controllers, a new inverter, additional solar panels, and a new generator. Welded steel structures include a garage, chicken coop, sheds, and livestock shelters, with fencing in place. Agricultural zoning supports animals, gardening, ranch use, or a self-sufficient homestead. Fourmile Creek adds a peaceful natural feature to the acreage, which also offers mountain and valley views, room to roam, and exceptional privacy. A professional survey with markers every 100 feet supports future planning. Conveniently located near Hartsel, Fairplay, Buena Vista, and Breckenridge, this Central Colorado property offers access to abundant outdoor recreation while maintaining the seclusion of rural mountain living. Ideal as a full-time residence, high-country retreat, working homestead, or off-grid getaway.

2400 Fourmile Creek Rd, Hartsel

$774,500

2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 4205900 MLS

An Outdoor Paradise located less than 30 miles from the geographical center of the Centennial State at 9,400 feet in elevation. This property is in a peaceful & relaxed atmosphere, yet within 6 miles from highway 285 or 24 on a county maintained/plowed road for all year access. Buena Vista is an easy 25 minutes away and Denver or Colorado Springs is within 2 hours. Ranch of the Rockies HOA includes central trash service, dog park, pavilion, and a stocked fishing reservoir for all property owners and guests. This beautiful property includes a stucco home (minimizes outdoor maintenance in Colorado’s climate), a 1,500 sq ft second metal outbuilding sufficient for storage, beautiful shop and extra garage space and an attractive driveway entry/arch. The walk out composite deck is spectacular for watching the red tail hawks soaring or other wildlife roaming the area like deer, elk, pronghorns, jackrabbits, cottontails, and blue birds, among others. The property is walking distance to the entrance to Pike/San Isabel National Forrest that provides hiking, biking, 4 wheeling, snowshoeing, cross country skiing and many other outdoor activities. It is less than 15 minutes from trophy trout fishing in Antero Reservoir and within 40 minutes of Gold Metal trout fishing on either the South Platte River or the Arkansas River, not to mention about 40 minutes from Spinney Mountain Reservoir, home to the best trophy trout and pike fishing in the state. There are numerous other smaller streams and lakes in the area and some call this the “Fly Fishing Capitol of Colorado”. There are 3 or 4 major ski areas within an hour drive in the winter and more than 10 of the state’s 54 14ers are within an hour’s drive to the trailhead. The 5-acre vacant lot next door is also available for purchase if you want to have an extra buffer. You must see this to truly appreciate it.

5675 Ranch Rd, Hartsel

$349,950

2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 6025768 MLS

Have you been waiting to have a wonderful mountain retreat in a beautiful tranquil setting ? how about a great hunting cabin within the draw area of GMU 57/58?Well here it is. This two bedroom home with a open floor plan has just been updated inside and out. With new appliances,fresh paint both interior and exterior, flooring, on demand hot water, newer solar system and batteries,gutters and much more. The brand new deck brings the breathtaking expansive views to the palm of your hands. This turnkey home on 5 plus acres is so comfortable that you will want to (and can) make this a permanent home. Want to have extraordinary privacy but stay in touch? How about High Speed Fiber Optic already installed!! located in Badger Creek Ranch, an exquisite off grid community that's just a scenic 40 minute drive from Buena Vista for all your needs. Bring all your mountain toys to enjoy the miles and miles of National forest trails and roads just down the road from this updated retreat. Although the Property Owners Association is voluntary ($50 annually) it is recommended as a great resource and meeting the friendly neighbor. Please see supplements for a full list of improvements.

1651 Aspen Trl, Hartsel

$269,000

1 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 9689195 MLS

Welcome home to your quaint adobe off grid home sitting on 5 acres! The layout of this home has great use of its 758 square feet! Kick off your shoes in your entry and then enter into your open living, dining, and kitchen combo space. The large windows flood this space with natural light and great views. The wood burning stove and solar radiant heat are great sources of heat on those cold Colorado nights. Next is your primary suite and you are greeted by the same large windows, natural light, and views and adjoining bathroom. Your new home is on solar so there are no electric bills. If off grid living isn't for you, that's ok, connect to the grid! Pictures don't due this home justice so schedule your showing today and call this home tomorrow.

147 Sulky Ct, Hartsel

$365,000

2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 4499833 MLS

Escape to the quiet of the Colorado mountains in this cozy 2-bedroom, 1-bath cabin on 5 private acres just south of Fairplay. With beautiful mountain views and a peaceful setting, this charming cabin is the perfect place to slow down and enjoy the simple things- morning coffee on the porch, evenings around the fire, and time spent with family and friends. Whether you're looking for a weekend getaway, a place to make lasting memories, or a cabin with rental potential, this property offers the classic mountain lifestyle so many people come here to find.

2120 Oxford Dr, Hartsel

$599,000

2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 7486412 MLS

Location, Location, Location, Country Charmer with sweeping mountain views of South Park, Pikes Peak, Buffalo Peaks as well as the famous Mosquito Range. Brand new septic system just installed! Very well built 1,520 square foot home with a 1,560 Square Foot Garage set in a serene country setting. Located just 20 minutes from historic Buena Vista for fine dining, shopping, mountain adventures and the famous Arkansas River known for world class rafting adventures. Less than 2 miles from Hwy 285/24 and 2 separate National Forest access points for seemingly endless trails and outdoor adventures. The Ranch of the Rockies subdivision offers owners a 25 acre private fishing lake stocked with fish, a central trash service, an on-site Ranch Manager and office, RV water fill & waste dump, pavilion, horse boarding and Long and Short Term Rentals allowed! The main level of this country charmer features 2 bedrooms with 2 full bathrooms, an office space and a private, finished bonus room upstairs with tons of storage! The large garage features parking for 2 full size vehicles and a large finished area behind the parking area offering many options and possibilities for multiple uses. Must See! The excellent private well, with a new pump, is approved for watering of horses! The 2.5 acre parcel has the perfect mix of large mature pine trees and aspen trees and those incredible views! All roads in the area are County Maintained and offer easy year round access! Back up generator in place! Only 2 hours from Denver, 1.5 hours from Colorado Springs and only 1 hour to Breckenridge Ski Resort for world class skiing! Fish nearby Antero Reservoir, Eleven Mile Canyon Reservoir and State Park, Spinney Mountain Reservoir and State Park and endless Gold Medal Waters including the “Dream Stream”. Tons of wildlife in the area including large herds of Elk, Deer and Pronghorn Antelope! Located in the heart of Colorado and EVERYTHING the Great Rocky Mountains have to offer!

2660 Campfire Rd, Hartsel

$570,000

2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 8877106 MLS

Mountain home in the Ranch of the Rockies Move-In Ready! Escape to your own private mountain haven with this charming 2-bedroom, 2-bath one level home nestled in a peaceful aspen grove and on 5 stunning acres. Offering incredible mountain and valley views from the newly built deck, this property is a rare opportunity to own a well-built and beautifully maintained home in the heart of Colorado's outdoor paradise. Step inside and enjoy vaulted ceilings in every room, a coffered ceiling and new flooring in the living room, oversized windows, and recessed lighting that make the space feel bright and open. The centrally located kitchen flows seamlessly into the dining and living areas—perfect for entertaining or cozy nights by the wood-burning fireplace. The primary suite features its own bath and serene views, while the second bedroom and bath provide comfortable space for guests or family. Surrounded by mature Aspen and Pine trees, this home is tucked into the center of the lot, maximizing privacy and the beauty of the natural surroundings—especially stunning during the fall colors. The Ranch of the Rockies offers a 25-acre private fishing lake for owners and your guests, stocked annually, RV storage, dump station, Central trash service, Dog Park and a caretaker for peace of mind, Property Highlights: 2 Bedrooms 2 Full Bathrooms, Vaulted Ceilings Throughout | Coffered Living Room Ceiling, Oversized Windows | Recessed Lighting, Cozy Wood-Burning Fireplace, Tremendous Mountain & Valley Views, Centered on 5 Gorgeous Wooded Acres, Mature Aspen & Pine Trees, Minutes to Buena Vista, the world famous Arkansas River & Outdoor Recreation. Easy Year-Round Access on County maintained roads. Close to 3 National Forest access points for seemingly endless trails.

8575 Ranch Rd, Hartsel

$549,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 9395406 MLS

Rare Opportunity to be the first to occupy this Beautiful, Newly Constructed Ranch Style Home! One Level, Split Bedroom Design with Centrally Located Family Room. No Stairs! High Vaulted Interior with Tongue and Groove Pine Ceilings. Custom Crafted, Hand Built Kitchen boasting Ample Cabinetry, a large Kitchen Island and Tons of Counter Space. Solid Wood Cabinet construction with Beetle Kill Pine gives this Kitchen True Colorado Character! No particle board here and built to last. Check out the Beautiful Acacia Hardwood Tops and Island Storage with pull-outs and Ample Storage. Large Windows in the Living Room allow for great Natural Light, Passive Solar Heat, and Beautiful Sweeping Views of the Colorado Countryside. Incredible Sunrises and Sunsets flow into the home! A large Wood Burning Stove with Rock Hearth keeps the Living Room very cozy on the snowiest Winter Day! The Open Floor Plan Design and exceptional layout utilizes all 1800 Square Feet to the best advantage, feeling very spacious, practical and functional. Must See! LVT Flooring with No Carpet! Enjoy 3 Spacious Bedrooms with the Primary Bedroom Suite split and separated from the Guest Bedrooms! Minimal traffic on a private, Cul-De-Sac Road! Quality Metal Roof and Insulated Concrete Forms (ICF's) The HOA, at only $245 a year, offers Central Trash Service, RV Storage, RV Water Fill and an RV Dump Station, Horse Boarding and a Large Private Fishing Lake for you and your guests! Full Time Ranch Manager on site also! There are 2 National Forest Access Points in the Ranch, also 3 Lakes and Gold Medal Waters close by. Tons of Wildlife in the area! Located close to Buena Vista, the Collegiate Peaks Mountain Range and the World Famous Arkansas River! Short drives to Denver and Colorado Springs. Just over an hour to Breckenridge Ski Resort! This home is located in the Heart of everything Colorado has to offer! This is a Newly Constructed, move in ready home! Call Today for more information or to schedule a tour!

59 Whip Way, Hartsel

$330,000

2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 6837957 MLS

Welcome to your perfect mountain escape in the Heart of Colorado! This charming 2-bedroom, 1-bath mountain home sits on a beautifully treed parcel with expansive, unobstructed mountain views in every direction. Thoughtfully updated, the home features new windows, new interior and exterior doors, a brand-new oven, new washer, and new gutters—giving you peace of mind and modern comfort the moment you move in. A true highlight of the property is the wrap-around deck, the ideal spot to sip your morning coffee, watch wildlife wander through the trees, or unwind in the evenings as the sun sets over the Rockies. This is Colorado outdoor living at its best. Step inside to find a warm, cozy layout perfect for relaxing after a day of exploring everything Hartsel has to offer. Outside, enjoy the quiet of towering pines, star-filled skies, and the wide-open feel this area is known for. Located just minutes from prime Colorado recreation, you’re perfectly positioned for world-class fishing at Eleven Mile, Spinney, and Antero Reservoirs, endless hiking and wildlife watching, and quick access to National Forest and BLM lands. Hartsel’s central location places you within an easy drive of Breckenridge, Buena Vista, Fairplay, and Colorado Springs, while still offering the peaceful seclusion mountain living is all about. Whether you’re searching for a full-time residence, a weekend retreat, or a smart investment opportunity, this Hartsel gem checks all the boxes. Don’t miss your chance to own a slice of true Colorado mountain living!

587 Willow St, Hartsel

$745,000

4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 6408813 MLS

Newly constructed in 2025, this custom earth-sheltered style home sits on 3 acres with no HOA. Thoughtfully designed to take advantage of Colorado’s abundant natural sunlight for passive solar heating, the home also features milled beams and woodwork throughout that add warmth and character. The floor plan includes 4 bedrooms offering flexibility for guests, working from home, or additional living space. A wood-burning stove keeps things cozy, while the interior flower bed is a unique feature that brings a little of the outdoors inside. The home is equipped with a multi-stage water filtration system designed to treat the well water, including iron and sediment filtration, reverse osmosis, mineral treatment, and a 200-gallon storage reservoir. Additional features include a metal roof and a walipini-style earth-sheltered greenhouse for gardening at elevation. Enjoy the privacy and space of 3 acres while still being about 20 minutes from Fairplay and 35 minutes from Buena Vista. The location offers easy access to everything the Colorado mountains have to offer, including hiking, fishing, rafting, camping, biking, and miles of surrounding mountains, rivers, and public lands to explore.

121 Co Rd 53, Hartsel

$599,999

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 4344155 MLS

One of the best values currently available in Ranch of the Rockies! This move-in-ready 3-bedroom, 3-bath mountain home offers over 2 private acres, breathtaking mountain views, a heated oversized detached 3-car garage, and a newly installed roof with a transferable warranty—all at an exceptional price point. Designed for comfortable Colorado mountain living, the open-concept floor plan welcomes you with vaulted tongue-and-groove ceilings, durable LVP flooring, a cozy wood-burning stove, and expansive mountain views enjoyed from both the living room and covered front porch. The well-appointed kitchen offers granite countertops, a gas range, newer appliances, abundant cabinetry, and an adjoining mudroom for added functionality. The spacious primary suite offers a walk-in closet and private ensuite bath, while two additional bedrooms provide flexibility for guests, a home office, or family. One of the standout features of this property is the oversized detached garage. Complete with electricity, heat, and an existing bathroom, it's the perfect space for a workshop, hobby area, home gym, "man cave," or could even offer future conversion potential for additional living space or guest quarters. Looking for room to grow? An adjacent subdivided 2.23-acre lot is also available for purchase, creating a rare opportunity for additional privacy, future expansion, investment, or resale. Located in the highly desirable Ranch of the Rockies community, residents enjoy year-round maintained roads, central trash service, RV storage, horse facilities, and private community amenities, all while being less than 25 minutes from Buena Vista, Fairplay, reservoirs, hiking, fishing, ATV trails, and endless Colorado recreation. Whether you're searching for a full-time residence, mountain getaway, or investment opportunity, this property delivers exceptional value, versatility, and the Colorado lifestyle buyers dream about.

1948 Wagon Wheel Rd, Hartsel

Start Your Search

The real estate listing information and related content displayed on this site is provided exclusively for consumers’ personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. This information and related content is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed accurate by the Pikes Peak REALTOR® Services Corp d/b/a elevateMLS.

The content relating to real estate for sale in this Web site comes in part from the Internet Data eXchange (“IDX”) program of METROLIST, INC., DBA RECOLORADO® Real estate listings held by brokers other than Above The Clouds Mountain Properties are marked with the IDX Logo. This information is being provided for the consumers’ personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any other purpose. All information subject to change and should be independently verified. IDX Terms and Conditions